South Africa
Capital city — Pretoria
Incarceration rate (per 100,000 inhabit…
i10/2022Country population
i2022Type of government
iCentral Intelligence Agency, The World Factbook - South AfricaHuman Development Index
0.713(109/191)
iHomicide rate (per 100,000 inhabitants)
i2021Name of authority in charge of the pris…
Total number of prisoners
i31/03/2023/ Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional ServicesPrison density
143 %According to the…
i11/08/2023Total number of prison facilities
243As of March 2022,…
i31/03/2022/ Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, p. 13.An NPM has been established
yes, in 2019On 19 July 2019,…
Female prisoners
i31/03/2023/ Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional ServicesIncarcerated minors
0.1 %Sixty-five childr…
i31/03/2023/ Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional ServicesPercentage of untried prisoners
35.6 %The high rate of…
i31/03/2023/ Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional ServicesDeath penalty is abolished
yes, since 1997The last executio…
iTogether against the death penalty (ECPM), Worldmap
Special populations
Women
Female prisoners
Variation in the number of female prisoners
increase
The number of female prisoners increased by 24.8% between March 2022 (3,724) and March 2023 (4,649).
Percentage of untried female prisoners
Percentage of foreign female prisoners
-
As of March 2022, there were 555 foreign national female prisoners.1
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, pp. 85-86. ↩
Women are incarcerated in specific units or in separate buildings within large prison complexes. Separate buildings are more commonly found in urban centres.
The following facilities have specific buildings for women:
-
Durban
-
East London
-
Johannesburg
-
Kgosi Mampuru II
-
Oudtshoorn
-
Pollsmoor
-
Thohoyandou
-
Worcester
The following facilities have specific units for women:
-
Bethal
-
Bizzah Makhate Medium C
-
Eshowe
-
Kimberley
-
Kokstad
-
Mafikeng
-
Nelspruit
-
Newcastle
-
Port Elizabeth
-
Upington
-
Vryheid
There is an effective separation between men and women
Male and female prisoners must be kept separate (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 7.2). The keys for a women’s unit or section must always be in the possession of a female correctional official. Any male visiting a female must be accompanied by a female correctional official at all times (Regulations to the Correctional Services Act, Regulation 3.2).
Girls and boys must be kept separate. Girls must remain under the supervision of a female officer (Child Justice Act 75 of 2008, Section 33.1).
Untried female prisoners are separated from the convicted
The prison staff is
male and female
This applies in male and female units.
Searches must be conducted by a correctional official of the same gender. The other gender must not be present (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 27.3b). In practice, sources indicate that a male officer may remain at the door or just outside during searches. Incarcerated women report feeling a lack of privacy in these situations. They also report feeling uncomfortable when male officers conduct cell searches during which they may touch their undergarments. There are no operating procedures to prevent male officers from doing so.
The Department of Correctional Services’ (DCS) Health Care Policy and Procedures Manual details provisions for gender-specific care. For example, women must benefit from Pap smears, and mammograms if they have a personal or family history of pre-menopausal breast cancer.1 In practice, civil society organisations report that specific health services focus on pre- and post-natal care, but do not extend to preventive screenings such as for cervical or breast cancer. They frequently report a lack of access to specialist medical care for women. Getting an appointment can take weeks if not months. Even for those with chronic illnesses, a single phone call with a specialist can be difficult to obtain.
Most facilities provide sanitary products free of charge.
Women can submit a request for an abortion in writing to a nurse. The prison governor and Area Manager must be informed. The National Commissioner may approve an abortion at State expense on medical grounds (Regulations to the Correctional Services Act, Regulation 7.9). Requests during the first 12 weeks or for socio-economic reasons are not covered. Different sources note that abortion is highly stigmatised and very difficult to obtain.
Lawyers for Human Rights observes that most women in prison have trauma and a long history of abuse and violence in their lives. Support for these experiences is virtually non-existent. Some are even afraid to leave prison because of the violent environment to which they will return.
Department of Correctional Services, “Health Care Policy and Procedures Manual”, paragraph 2.11. ↩
Incarcerated women must be allowed to participate in activities, training and work. Programmes that take into consideration the specific needs of women must be provided (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 41.7). In practice, different sources indicate that activities are highly gendered and much more limited than in men’s facilities. Activities may include sewing, flower arranging or handicrafts. Work may include hairdressing or styling. Business courses and manual work such as woodwork are generally reserved for male prisoners.
-
In 2024, the prison service reported that programmes were rolled out according to the needs of the female prisoners, identified during the initial evaluation. Available programmes addressed gender-based violence awareness, anger management, sexual offences, substance abuse, restorative justice, behaviour modification in response to gangsterism, and programmes to prepare for release.
Conjugal visits are allowed for women
legislation does not provide for conjugal visits
Pregnant women are housed in specific units or cells
no
Pregnant women must be accommodated in the hospital section at night from the sixth month of pregnancy (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 12). The National Commissioner must, “within the Department’s available resources”, ensure that specific units are available for pregnant remand prisoners (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 49A).
In practice, sentenced and unsentenced women are generally only placed in a specific medical unit, or sent to the hospital, if they are experiencing a particular medical problem related to their pregnancy.
Women in pre-trial detention must be allowed to inform their relatives of their pregnancy. They may also request additional visits with the biological father, relatives or other supportive persons (Regulations to the Correctional Services Act, Regulation 26D).
The legislation provides for a sentence adjustment for pregnant women or women with young children
Pregnant women receive proper prenatal care
Pregnant women must receive pre and postnatal care, including basic health education on childcare and family planning. They must be consulted by a doctor at least once a month. During the last four weeks of pregnancy, these visits should take place at least once a week (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 12). Infants must receive appropriate supervision during the day, for the first three months, if their mother is unable to care for them for medical reasons (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 8). Women in pre-trial detention must have access to pre, intra and postnatal care. Pregnant and lactating women must have their nutritional needs provided for as prescribed in the Department of Health’s Maternal Health Guidelines (Regulations to the Correctional Services Act, Regulation 26D).
Childbirth takes place in
external care facilities
The father should be able to be present if it is considered in the interests of all parties involved (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 18.14).
Security staff is prohibited from entering the room during labour and childbirth
Sources indicate that a female official often sits inside the room or right outside the door.
The use of instruments of restraint is forbidden during labour and childbirth
-
Sources indicate that women in labour and delivery are most often cuffed to the bed by their hands or ankles. Doctors frequently insist that the restraints be removed, but these requests are generally ignored.
Mothers are allowed to keep their children with them
yes, until 2 years old
According to the JICS, there are 85 infants incarcerated with their mothers as of 31 March 2023.
Contact visits must be ensured with the father and other family members. Mothers must be provided with child development and stimulation programmes (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 16.7).
The clothes and possessions of infants must be thoroughly searched upon admission and as often as deemed necessary (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraph 20.1).
The National Commissioner must ensure, “where practicable”, that a mother and child unit is available for women incarcerated with their children (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 20.3). These units must promote physical, social and mental development. Its staff is responsible for providing care and protecting the infants against sexual and child abuse. Mothers must receive counselling, guidance and training to develop their parenting skills. Infants must sleep in cots in the same cell as their mother and be provided with bedding (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraphs 5-6). These units are usually located in a secure room with painted walls and toys, sometimes with a playroom.
In 2020, the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) reported that some mother and child units are inadequate, small and lack baby cots. Structurally, the doors make a loud banging noise similar to other cell doors when being closed, locked and unlocked. The SAHRC considers that this can have adverse psychological effects on the development of infants. The mother and child unit at Oudtshoorn Female Correctional Centre was found to be heavily infested with cockroaches.1
South African Human Rights Commission, National Preventive Mechanism, Annual Report 2019-2020, p. 34. ↩
Security staff wear standard uniforms when working in mother and child care units.
The prison administration provides an Early Childhood Development (ECD) programme, which entails support services and systems for mother and child care units. Infants must be provided with food, clothing, health care and facilities that promote their development (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 20.3). Food must be in accordance with the dietary scale and their unique needs. The prison administration is responsible for all infant medical costs. Those with disabilities are entitled to specialised care. The fact that an infant is born in prison may not appear on their birth certificate. They must be provided with adequate clothing, as well as with toys that promote their physical, psychological and emotional development. A nurse must be assigned at every correctional centre to manage the supervision of all the infants. Officials and prisoners (called ‘infant-minders’) working in the mother and child unit must be specially trained and selected based on specific criteria. They must complete a departmental course in childcare. ‘Infant-minders’ may not have been convicted for a violent crime (B-Orders, chapter 8, paragraphs 8, 9, 11, 15, 17).
Minors
The law bans the imprisonment of minors
Minimum age of imprisonment for minors
14
The Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 states that a child under the age of 12 does not have criminal capacity and may not be prosecuted. A child between the ages of 12 and 14 does not have criminal capacity unless otherwise proven by the State (Section 7).
Children over the age of 14 may be prosecuted and sentenced to imprisonment for a maximum of 25 years. Eligibility for early release may not be restricted. Placement in prison prior to sentencing must be reconsidered every 14 days (Sections 30, 77).
Incarcerated minors
Sixty-five children are awaiting trial. One sentenced child is a girl.
Variation in the number of incarcerated minors
increase
The number of incarcerated minors increased by 15.3% between 31 March 2022 (85)1 and 31 March 2023 (98).
Department of Correctional Service, Annual Report 2021/22, p. 71. ↩
Ministry in charge of incarcerated minors
Ministry of Justice and Correctional Services
The Depart of Correctional Services (prison administration) is responsible for incarcerated children. The Ministry of Social Development is responsible for all other minors in conflict with the law.
Minors are subject to the Child Justice Act 75 of 2008.
The Child Justice Act 75 of 2008 sets out the following sentencing options (Chapter 10, Part 2):
-
community-based sentence
-
restorative justice
-
fine, symbolic restitution, financial compensation, obligation to provide a service or benefit
-
correctional supervision
-
compulsory residence in a child and youth care centre (CYCC)
-
imprisonment
Only imprisonment and correctional supervision as part of a prison sentence are managed by the prison administration.
There are 15 juvenile and youth centres in which children are held:
-
Barberton Town
-
Boksburg Juvenile
-
Brandvlei Juvenile
-
Cofimvaba
-
Cradock
-
Drakensteyn Youth
-
Durban Juvenile
-
Ekuseni
-
Emthonjeni Juvenile
-
Modimole
-
Mosselbay Youth
-
Mount Ayliff
-
Pollsmoor Medium A
-
Rustenburg Medium A
-
Rustenburg Medium B
Figures on minors in prison are published
annually
Minors in prison are separated from adults
yes
The prison administration uses the following terms for the corresponding age groups:
-
children (minors): <18
-
juvenile: 18-21
-
youth: 22-25
Children, juveniles and youths must all be detained separately (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 7.2; Regulations to the Correctional Services Act, Regulation 3.2).
The law provides for single cell accommodation for minors
no
The schooling of minors is compulsory
The Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998 states that children are subject to compulsory education programmes (Section 19.1). The prison administration states that children under 15 years old are required to go to school and follow the curriculum prescribed by the Department of Education.
The law prohibits strip searches for minors
The law forbids solitary confinement for minors
Incarcerated children must be provided with recreational, religious, psychological and social work services. The prison administration must also, “if practicable”, foster family contact through additional visits and other means (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 19).
Foreign prisoners
Number and percentage of foreign prisoners
Variation in the number of foreign prisoners
increase
The number of foreign prisoners increased by 26.3% between 30 September 2021 (12,178)1 and 30 September 2022 (16,518).
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Second Quarterly Performance Report 1 July - 30 September 2021, p. 9. ↩
As of 30 September 2022, the most represented foreign nationalities are Mozambique, Lesotho, and Tanzania.1 As of 31 March 2023, the most represented nationalities serving life sentences are Mozambique (139) and Zimbabwe (193).2
Foreign prisoners of the same nationality are generally kept together.3
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Second Quarterly Performance Report 1 July - 30 September 2022, p. 51. ↩
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, pp. 30, 86. ↩
Foreign & Commonwealth Office, Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, Guidance, South Africa: prisoner pack, p.13 ↩
Foreign prisoners are informed of their right to communicate with their consular representatives
-
Foreign nationals can communicate with consular representatives. When the latter is not possible, they may communicate with a diplomatic representative or an international organisation (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 13.5).
Lawyers for Human Rights notes that, in practice, a foreign national’s respective embassy is informed on their detention, but prisoners do not have the possibility to contact them. The Embassy determines whether to approach the individual or not.
The prison regulations are translated for foreign prisoners
yes
Prison regulations must be provided in a language that the incarcerated person can understand, using an interpreter if necessary (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 6.4).
Foreign prisoners are entitled to legal aid
Foreign nationals may also benefit from legal aid services.1
See Access to rights for more information.
Foreign & Commonwealth Office, Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, Guidance, South Africa: prisoner pack ↩
Illegal residence can be punishable with imprisonment. The Immigration Act 13 of 2002 states that any person who enters, remains in or leaves the territory in contravention of the Act is guilty of an offence and liable to a fine or to imprisonment for a period not exceeding two years (Section 49).
Foreign prisoners are allowed to remain in the country after having served their sentence
under certain circumstances
Foreign nationals are not allowed to return to South Africa within their parole period. They may request authorisation from the Department of Home Affairs following the end of their parole period (B-Orders, chapter 17, paragraph 18.2).
Foreign prisoners are allowed to work while incarcerated
Foreign prisoners have access to payphones and can call their home country.1
Foreign & Commonwealth Office, Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, Guidance, South Africa: prisoner pack, p. 13. ↩
Lawyers for Human Rights notes that visiting adjustments are largely at the discretion of officials. Visitors coming from afar may be granted up to an hour and a half instead of the standard 45 minutes.
Long-term prisoners
A long-term sentence is considered as such as of
2 years
Prisoners sentenced to more than 24 months are subject to different provisions of the law, particularly in terms of sentence adjustments such as eligibility for parole and placement under correctional supervision or community corrections.
Cumulative sentences have a limit
Determinate sentences are served concurrently with life sentences, ‘habitual criminal’ sentences (15 years), and ‘dangerous criminal’ sentences.
Life sentences and ‘dangerous criminal’ sentences are also served concurrently.
Multiple determinate sentences are not served concurrently unless otherwise specified by the court (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 39.2).
There are specific prison facilities for long-term prisoners
Long-term prisoners are not subject to a specific prison regime. Rights and amenities are based on their security classification.
Life sentences are banned
People serving a life sentence
17 %
A total of 464 prisoners sentenced to life are foreign nationals as of 30 September 2022.1
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Second Quarterly Performance Report 1 July - 30 September 2022, p. 53. ↩
Variation in the number of people serving a life sentence
increase
Offences that used to carry the death penalty, until it was abolished in 1997, are now mostly punishable by life imprisonment. The number of prisoners sentenced to life increased by approximately 4240% between 1995 (400) and 2022 (17,373).
A life sentence can be imposed for the following offenses:
-
premeditated murder
-
murder committed alongside a robbery with aggravating circumstances
-
rape of a person under the age of 16
-
rape of a person who is physically or mentally disabled
-
rape where the survivor was raped more than once (whether by the perpetrator or a co-perpetrator or accomplice (‘gang rape’)
-
rape when the perpetrator knew they were HIV-positive
-
human trafficking
-
terrorism
-
genocide and crimes against humanity
There are specific prison facilities for life-sentenced prisoners
Life-sentenced prisoners are not subjected to a specific prison regime.
Eligibility for parole depends on the date of sentencing and the length of time served. Prisoners sentenced between March 1994 and June 1998 must have served 15 years of their sentence to be eligible. Those sentenced between July 1998 and September 2004 must have served 12 years and four months.
Parole eligibility for prisoners sentenced after September 2004 depends on the date on which the offense was committed. Prisoners having committed the offense before 1 October 2004 must have served 12 years and four months to 15 years. The current parole regime establishes that prisoners having committed offenses after 1 October 2004 must have served 25 years before becoming eligible.1
The request must be submitted to the Correctional Supervision and Parole Board and to the National Council for Correctional Services. The latter must then submit a recommendation to the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services, who renders the decision (Section 136.3). If the Minister denies the request, the case must be re-examined within two years (Section 78).
The National Council submitted 1,009 recommendations to the Minister during 2021/22. The Minister granted parole to 186 prisoners sentenced to life and referred 495 cases back to the prison administration. A further 328 cases were not processed. As of 31 March 2022, 4,362 prisoners sentenced to life were eligible for parole. Many have already been eligible for years. The JICS frequently receives complaints regarding parole and the lack of feedback from the National Council. There is a substantial backlog of cases to be considered by the Minister. This problem has existed for several years.2
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, pp. 9, 30, 42, 77. ↩
Ibid. ↩
Untried prisoners
Percentage of untried prisoners
The high rate of untried prisoners is attributed to “arrests based on insufficient evidence for prosecution, overburdened courts, poor case preparation, irregular access to public defenders, and prohibitive bail amounts”.1
U.S. Department of State, 2022 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: South Africa - Pretrial Detention. ↩
Variation in the number of untried prisoners
increase
The number of untried prisoners increased by 18.5% between 31 March 2022 (47,164)1 and 31 March 2023 (55,870).
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, p. 9. ↩
Untried prisoners are separated from the convicted
Sentenced and unsentenced prisoners must be kept separately (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 7.2). Most correctional centres accommodate both populations in different sections.1 Prolonged pre-trial detention in correctional centres is a growing concern for the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), as it contributes significantly to overcrowding.2
Remand detention facilities do not provide rehabilitation or other structured programmes.3 Many of them do not have the appropriate infrastructure or sufficient budgets to meet basic needs.4
Correctional and remand centres may serve one or more districts. An accused person may be held in a police cell for up to seven days if a district does not have a reference centre (Section 5.2).
The SAHRC is increasingly concerned about the prolonged detention of awaiting trial prisoners in police cells. Reasons for the prolonged detention can be attributed to extensions of the pre-trial detention period and to short period court reappearances. In remote areas, the lack of access to vehicles exacerbates this issue. Most of the police cells are overcrowded, dilapidated, dirty and lack lighting and ventilation. Adequate clothing, blankets and mattresses are not provided. Recreational activities are limited and food provisions are not upheld. The need for medication in the event of injury or illness is not guaranteed.5
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, p. 21. ↩
South African Human Rights Commission, National Preventive Mechanism, Annual Report 2020-2021, p. 32-34. ↩
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, p. 21. ↩
South African Human Rights Commission, National Preventive Mechanism, Annual Report 2020-2021, p. 32-34. ↩
South African Human Rights Commission, National Preventive Mechanism, Annual Report 2019-2020, pp. 7, 28, 37-40. ↩
The law provides for release on bail for untried prisoners
Untried prisoners must have the possibility to apply for bail within 48 hours.1
As of 30 September 2022, 2,606 people in pre-trial detention could be released on bail of less than R 1,000 (EUR 50) but could not afford to pay it. The JICS highlights that this situation also contributes to overcrowding.2 Inspecting Judge, Edwin Cameron, refers to them as “prisoners of poverty”.
The African Policing Civilian Oversight Forum highlights that other difficulties are encountered in obtaining bail. These include dysfunctional administrative and judicial procedures, as well as the lack of an individualised approach.
Foreign & Commonwealth Office, Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office, Guidance, South Africa: prisoner pack, pp. 19-20. ↩
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Second Quarterly Performance Report 1 July - 30 September 2022, p. 50. ↩
Pre-trial detention must not exceed two years, unless extended by the court. The head of the remand detention facility must report cases of untried prisoners biannually to the relevant Director of Public Prosecutions. Cases exceeding two years must be reported annually to the court (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 49G).
Lawyers for Human Rights indicates that provisions for reviews are not upheld. Pre-trial detention frequently exceeds the maximum sentence for the alleged offence. The average wait time before trial was 176 days in 2021/22.1 As of 31 March 2022, 27 people had been awaiting trial for more than seven years.2
The placement of children in prison prior to sentencing must be reconsidered every 14 days (Child Justice Act 75 of 2008, Section 77). The time spent awaiting trial in a correctional centre or a child and youth care centre must count towards the total sentence of incarceration imposed (Section 77.5).
U.S. Department of State, 2022 Country Reports on Human Rights Practices: South Africa - Pretrial Detention. ↩
Judicial Inspectorate for Correctional Services, Annual Report 2021 -2022, p. 9. ↩
All prisoners have the right to challenge the lawfulness of their detention in person before a court (Constitution (Section 35.2).
Untried prisoners are entitled to the same provisions as sentenced prisoners, alongside additional rights, such as more visits and phone calls. In practice, their access to activities, work and support programmes is more limited than for sentenced prisoners.
Minorities or indigenous people
Data collection about prisoners’ minority or indigenous background is allowed
Data is only collected on the language spoken.
Minority or indigenous backgrounds are criteria for specific cell or unit assignment
no
Prisoners belonging to specific minority or indigenous groups are not subject to a particular prison regime.
The specific needs of prisoners are taken into account with regard to
- language
- religion
- dietary restrictions
LGBTQI+ people
The prosecution or imprisonment of a person on the grounds of their sexual orientation or gender identity is banned
The Constitution stipulates that the State may not directly or indirectly discriminate, against anyone on the grounds of gender, sex, or sexual orientation (Section 9).
LGBTQI+ persons are separated from other prisoners
-
The Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on the management of LGBTQI+ prisoners states that people in situations of vulnerability must be detained separately from others (Section 7.5). This provision is generally upheld. Transgender males, transgender females, intersex males and intersex females must be incarcerated and transported separately (Section 7.4 & 8.1).1 Lawyers for Human Rights reports that placement is based on self-reporting of sexual and gender orientation, which is not always done by prisoners for fear of discrimination. Separation is sometimes experienced as punishment due to isolation and/or mistreatment by officials.
Department of Correctional Services, “Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on the management of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and queer plus inmates”, March 2020. ↩
The prison administration must implement measures to create a gender sensitive environment for all prisoners (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 16.4). A risk and needs assessment must be carried out within six hours of admission to determine whether a person is vulnerable to sexual violence or other forms of exploitation (Section 7.1.1). A security risk evaluation must be completed within 24 hours to determine proper placement as well as the necessary personnel and resources required to keep the prisoner safe and secure (Section 7.1.2). Prison governors must ensure that officials receive training based on the SOPs (Section 8.3.6).1
Civil society organisations were seemingly not consulted in the drafting of the new SOPs. Just Detention International - South Africa (JDI-SA) considers that the document lacks substance, providing mainly a glossary of terms, without developing specific policy such as staff training and access to healthcare. Despite training requirements, officials often do not understand what LGBTQI+ means, nor the terms transgender, sexual orientation, gender identity, etc. JDI-SA does, however, provide training for officials on gender identity, sexual orientation, sex characteristics and prejudices against LGBTQI+ persons.
Department of Correctional Services, “Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on the management of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and queer plus inmates”, March 2020. ↩
Assignment of transgender prisoners to a specific facility depends on
their biological sex
Transgender prisoners are placed based on their biological sex at birth. They are held separately from other prisoners. Placement in secure care units is based on self-reporting which is not always done for fear of discrimination. The landmark September vs Subramoney N.O and Others case, judged by the Equality Court, in the Western Cape on 23 September 2019, sets the precedent for transgender persons to be able to express their gender through hairstyle, dress and make-up. It also orders officials to address transgender persons with appropriate pronouns and the prison administration to implement transgender sensitivity training for current and new employees.
Transgender prisoners are entitled to customised searches
The SOPs on the management of LGBTQI+ prisoners indicate that body cavity searches must be conducted by an official of the same gender (Section 7.3.4). The SOPs define gender identity as: “a person’s private sense of being male, female or another gender. This may or may not match the biological sex a person was assigned at birth”. (Section 5.10).1
Department of Correctional Services, “Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on the management of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and queer plus inmates”, March 2020. ↩
Transgender prisoners benefit from specific health care
-
The National Health Act 61 of 2003 only cites women, children, the elderly and persons with disabilities as groups in situations of vulnerability. The SOPs on the management of LGBTQI+ prisoners do not set out any provisions for specific healthcare.1 Lawyers for Human Rights notes that prisoners may, in some cases, continue hormone therapy at their own expense, including the cost of transportation and security.
Department of Correctional Services, “Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) on the management of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex, and queer plus inmates”, March 2020. ↩
Conjugal visits are allowed for LGBTQI+ prisoners
legislation does not provide for conjugal visits
Elderly prisoners
The are no special provisions for sentenced elderly persons.1 Facilities do not have specific handrails or ramps. In some correctional centres, the elderly may be held in medical units or separated from the rest of the population.
Lukas Muntingh, A Guide to the Rights of Inmates as Described in the Correctional Services Act and Regulations, 2017, p. 39. ↩
Prisoners aged over 65 and having served 15 years may be placed on day parole or parole (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 73.6).
Persons with disabilities
The prison service keeps a record of prisoners with disabilities
Prison facilities are adapted to the needs of prisoners with disabilities
no
The prison administration must implement measures, in terms of planning, policy and infrastructure, to accommodate prisoners with disabilities (Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998, Section 16.3). In practice, there are no handrails, ramps, or infrastructure-based modifications suited to accommodate prisoners with disabilities. Untried prisoners with disabilities may be held separately in a single or communal cell (Section 49B.1).
The Correctional Services Act 111 of 1998 defines a disability as “a physical, mental, intellectual or sensory impairment which prevents a person having such an impairment from operating in an environment developed for persons without such an impairment”. The prison administration must provide, “within its available resources”, additional health care services, as well as additional psychological services if recommended by a medical practitioner (Section 49B). Medical assistive devices such as wheelchairs, artificial limbs, dentures or glasses, may be issued at State expense.1
Lawyers for Human Rights reports that prisoners with disabilities often rely on informal assistance from officials or fellow prisoners.
Department of Correctional Services, “Health Care Policy and Procedures Manual”, paragraph 2.29. ↩
Death penalty prisoners
Death penalty is abolished
yes, since 1997
The last execution took place in 1991.